12 Best Carbon Steel Pan Reviews of 2021 You Can Buy


Carbon steel pans are somewhat such as cast iron pans, but they are a lot more resilient than the latter. They are made from approx 1 percent carbon and 99 percent iron. As a consequence of the distinctive makeup, carbon steel utensils may withstand considerable vital temperatures.

Being somewhat heavier than most other stuff, it sits well and securely on your stovetop and provides that strong feel to its looks that are robust. Generally safe for your oven, broiler, and harmonious with almost any heating source, this can be quite a versatile part of kitchenware.

So, have a look at the best carbon steel pan in the industry, and let’s get cooking…

List of 12 Best Carbon Steel Pan Reviews

1. BK Cookware Skillet Black Carbon Steel

BK Black Steel Skillet is a high-quality pan that’s also not expensive. Users will find a fantastic piece of cookware to get a lesser price tag, and that’s why we included this pan on the list.

If you’re working with a small budget, this might be the carbon steel pans for you. The pan is constructed from gray carbon steel. It’s 2mm thick and comes in 3 distinct sizes — 10, 11, and 12-inch. BK Black Steel Skillet is created completely of iron, so it’s safe to use in a single oven.

This pan is pre-seasoned and ready to use straight away. Some users had difficulties with the elimination of the silicone coating. If you do not do this step correctly, you can damage the pan’s surface, then diminishing the non-sticky properties.


  • The pan is budget-friendly.
  • Oven-safe.


  • You have to be really cautious when removing the protective coating.
  • The grips may be too long if you’re using this pan onto a little cooker.

2. De Buyer MINERAL B Round Carbon Steel Fry Pan

The De Buyer fry pan is sold in six dimensions to make sure that there’s one for everyone. Every one of them has a long handle that’s triple-riveted in place for security. Additionally, this handle remains ever-trendy for comfortable usage.

For the bigger pans, however, they have a helper handle for comfort and security.

This pan is PTFE and PFOA free; therefore, it is safe to use. And additional to its makeup is Bee Wax. This organic chemical-free element is used to take care of the De Buyer pans to create them oxidation resistant.

Also helping in seasoning, so you can make certain this pan has nothing but the very best to give you.


  • Six dimensions.
  • Ergonomic cool handles.
  • Chemical-free.
  • The infused beeswax helps boost the pan is nonstick.
  • Oxidation resistant.


  • Not oven secure.

3. MINERAL B Round Carbon Steel Fry Pan

This carbon steel pan is 100% natural, making it Quite eco-friendly.

It’s produced of pure 99% iron using bee wax finishing. This is supposed to stop oxidation, which eases rusting. For those men and women who like sealing, browning, and grilling as ways of cooking, then this is the pan for you.

Like top carbon steel pans, it is better with age because of the buildup of this nonstick facet on the surface. It’s better when the pan works darker—the patina thing.

The pan doesn’t have any chemical additives such as PTFE OR PFOA, producing its security really trustworthy.

The”a la Francaise” deal is curved, making it comfortable and easy to use.

The merit can be found in the customer’s request from the client services.


  • Ergonomic handle
  • Natural improvement for the nonstick finish
  • Free ​from any Additional substances
  • 100% organic and eco-friendly


  • Bee wax may melt
  • Limited size

4. Mauviel M’Steel, carbon, nonstick fry pan

Offering you a lifetime warranty, you want to find an idea of the grade that this pan brings to the table. Manufactured with commercial excellent stuff, it is capable of lasting many lifetimes over. It expands its own function to all as it is offered in five measurements to make sure unique users’ needs.

The Mauviel M’Steel comprises an extremely long ergonomic handle, which enables you to use it easily. This is triple riveted in the region for durability. The iron handle consists of a heavy gauge. Therefore it will not bend or break. Each one the stovetop compatible, you may use it with anything — also dishwasher safe, providing more flexibility.

It develops a natural nonstick that strengthens over time. This one, however, will not rust or oxidize because of being treated with beeswax.


  • Five measurements.
  • Ergonomic handle for comfortable use.
  • Rust and oxidation resistance.
  • Each of the stovetops is compatible.
  • Oven safe.
  • Lifetime warranty.


  • No helper handle on the larger versions.

5. BK Cookware CC002352-001 Black Carbon Steel Skillet

This ideal carbon steel pan is very resistant to corrosion, stains, and damage because of some high-temperature Black iron oxide coating and therefore is safe to be used with metal utensils. Their coated cast iron handles are firmly attached with rivets and shaped for comfort.

This shredder boats with a slender silicone wax coating that is easier to eliminate than a thick coating of beeswax or dirt, so it is ready to use after a quick wash using soap. Cleaning is as easy as massaging warm water, wiping, and then drying.

Designed to create a natural nonstick patina coating, this can be a pan for a lifetime. The longer you use it, the greater and more non-stick it’s. Metal utensil safe, oven safe up to 600°F.


  • Simple to wash
  • Fantastic Excellent material
  • Oven safe up to 600°F
  • Stainless steel substance which becomes equally heated and Carbon Steel coating


  • Heavy
  • Manage become heated

6. Lodge 12 Inch Seasoned Carbon Steel Skillet

Serving for over a hundred decades, Lodge is the most reliable brand all around the USA and on earth. You may imagine the high quality and functioning of a new which stays in the market for such a lengthy time, and this carbon steel pan is just another proof of high-quality products.

This carbon steel pan includes a 12-gauge structure, and its warmth retention is excellent also. The heat supply is fast, and even during the pan. The pan is well made and extremely durable so that it can withstand high temperatures, and this also makes it ideal for browning or searing meats.

The handle of the skillet can be exceptionally durable and will serve you for several decades. The treatment is also simple and fast because the pan weighs just 3 lbs. The cooking area is enough to cook various kinds of foods, and also, to be exact, it’s about 18.88 x 10 x 1.38 inches.

Last, you utilize this skillet on all cooktops, like gasoline, electrical, and at the oven.


  • The hottest and dependable manufacturer in the business.
  • It includes pre-seasoned for simplicity of usage.
  • You might even use it on camping trips


  • The interior surface of the pan isn’t even.

7. Matfer Bourgeat Black Steel Round Fry Pan

This Matfer Bourgeat skillet isn’t affordable, but if you’re working with an infinite budget, it might be a superb addition to your kitchen.

It’s sturdy, with slightly raised sides, which makes it quite versatile. You might even pop it in the oven when required. The pan comes in a variety of sizes, from 8 to 17-inch. Users can discover the specific size that suits their cooking needs, which is precisely why this pan is among them.

Additionally, it’s 2mm thick. The handle isn’t riveted to the pan, so parts of the food won’t be trapped there. On the other hand, the deficiency of rivets can make the deal more likely to breaking. The carbon steel pan is often mild, but you may see that this piece of cookware is somewhat hefty.


  • Many sizes to select from.
  • It may be utilized within an oven.


  • No rivets on the deal.
  • It is on the milder side compared to another pan on this listing.

8. Garcima 15-Inch Carbon Steel Paella Pan

Fantastic layout 1 pan, multiple applications. That’s precisely exactly what the Garcima team set in 1 place only for you. This 15-inch pan is big enough to hold a good deal whilst also having the ability to cook smaller amounts too. With this best carbon steel pan, you receive all of the stovetop compatibility.

Structured is the very best paella pan, so you may use this to cook whatever you prefer. But, it may also be set on your grill to make your fish, poultry, or other culinary pleasures. And, for the most flexibility, it’s also dishwasher safe.

With this item, you receive two handles for effortless carrying. The grips are cool; therefore, no worries. Its fine layout also makes it good for dining table parts. Its durability is, nevertheless, one of its strongest points is its own industrial-grade carbon steel structure.

You receive a free recipe book in the box. This may open you up to paella — along with a great deal more!


  • Wonderful layout and complete — appropriate for table parts.
  • Two cool handles for secure usage.
  • All stovetop is harmonious.
  • Versatile item.
  • Grill top appropriate.
  • Oven safe.
  • Free recipe book included.


  • Just 1 dimension variation.

9. Lodge Manufacturing Company carbon steel skillet

This multipurpose carbon steel pan comes in bigger sizes of approximately 12 inches, making it ideal for families or amusement.

They’re bought seasoned and are large enough to cook a lot of food sufficient for the sizeable audience. The deal is orange and made from silicon to give heat insulation of around 500-degrees F.

The winner concerning this pan is its own security to expose it.

The riveted handle create created for heavy-duty functions. This makes it ideal for professional and commercial kitchenware, particularly in regards to sear, sauté, and grill in addition to roast and fry.

Ultimately, besides it being beneficial for many cooktops, it’s extremely simple to keep.


  • The pan is experienced with a Pure easy-release complete that gets better with usage.
  • Suitable with all Kinds of the cooktop
  • It’s easy to maintain and care for it.​
  • Manage made from silicon that acts as an insulator
  • It’s safe to use in a dishwasher.


  • It is Somewhat big for simple domestic usage.
  • It’s quite heavy

10. Joyce Chen , Classic Series Carbon Steel Wok Set

For cooking lovers on the watch for a wok set usable on electricity along with gas cooktops, the Joyce Chen J21-9972DS-1 is your go-to collection. This particular collection involves a 14-inch wok, 12-inch bamboo spatula, dome lid, and some recipe booklet.

This series is created by 11/2inches of carbon dioxide, which leads to faster cooking with heat supply. The handle is much more preferable to use and made from birch wood, known to stay cool when utilized.

Therefore, you do not have to worry about getting your palms burnt while cooking. The pan also enables you to cook without using petroleum.


  • A thinner bottom using a wider upper enables heat preservation.
  • Non-stick dome lid
  • Carbon steel ensures fast & heat.


  • The jacket can divide during seasoning.
  • Might rust with routine use

11. MINERAL B Round Carbon Steel Steak Fry Pan

This pan out of De Buyer is somewhat different from some of the other offerings, but it nevertheless brings that fabled De Buyer caliber to the dining table instead of the stovetop.

Each of De Buyer’s pans features their specially made”a la Francaise” ergonomically curved handle, stamped with the”Made in France” guarantee.

Though the pan is lightweight at less than 3 lbs, it has a lot of cooking surfaces. The pan measures 17.8 x 9.5 x 1 inches that are sufficient to cook a fantastic steak, which this pan is designed to perform.

As time passes, the pan will turn out to be virtually non-existent as a result of appropriate seasoning but will nevertheless possess excellent heat retention properties. This pan may be used on all cooktops, even induction.

This pan can’t be washed in the dishwasher and doesn’t come pre-seasoned, but we’ll be describing the way to do so in only a little bit.


  • Simple to Deal with
  • Suitable for many cooktops Including Induction
  • Fantastic heat distribution Throughout the pan


  • Very heavy

12. Craft Wok Traditional Hand Hammered Carbon Steel Pow Wok Pan

In case you desire a traditional Chinese cooking wok, this great merchandise by Craft Wok is only the perfect fit. Apart from the traditional quick skillet and routine stirring, it might also be used for the deep frying pan or creating distinct curry or soups variants.

Exactly like other Chinese functions, this one might be used as a smoker or steamer. Produced from 15-gauge of carbon steel, this item comprises a wooden handle on one side and a steel helper attached to the other end.

You may have a generous amount of seasoning oil to ensure the appropriate skillet of any veggies or similar products.


  • Made from the carbon commercial-grade
  • The steel-based helper handle is Fantastic for hanging.
  • It could be used for stir fry, deep fry, or curries
  • Wooden handle That is heatproof.


  • Unsuitable for glass stoves or electrical.

Buying Guide for Best Carbon Steel Pans

Material Combo

Many manufacturers unite or coat their carbon steel pan along with different substances. Check to make certain the pan you’re purchasing does not include any additives.

While carbon steel pans will be best left with no coating to acquire the very best of their purpose, if you would like to avoid going via every seasoning, then purchase an enameled carbon steel pan.

The best, though, is to purchase a natural pre-seasoned pan. This way, you can enjoy up it from the box.

Source of heat

Some carbon steel pans are cooktop specific in spite of the fact that the majority of them are not. Before buying one, you should search for one which matches the cooktops or surfaces of the heating system, which you have to prevent inconveniences.

It’s quite a good idea to purchase one that’s versatile, one which goes nicely with any cooking surface that is given.

Easy To Clean

Ease of cleaning is also a substantial element. With the majority of carbon steel pans, then you should wash them with warm water and maybe only a little soap. At any time you do this, any foods have to come off easily, and you ought not to need to use anything stronger to wash it.


The dimensions of this carbon steel pan which you want to buy will depend completely on where you’d use it. Could you’re usually serving one or two individuals, or are you going to be using it for cooking for your whole family?

Obviously, the bigger the size, the heavier its weight will function as well. Just take these into account when deciding upon the proper pan that can fit your precise requirements.


This attribute needs to be ergonomic for relaxation. Better still, it ought to be ever trendy to improve your relaxation. Also, as correctly adjusted in place to encourage the pan’s fat.

If you’re striving for a bigger pan, then one using a helper handle ought to be preferred. Given the burden of those units, a huge pan with a helper handle is equally secure and also the most practical to utilize.

The price

The majority of the time, most of us need an item that’s pocket-friendly and very affordable. While this remains the case, we also ought to take into account the operation of the pan we wish to buy.

The big, heavy-duty, sturdy pans which are used commercially or professionally have a tendency to be costly when compared with the national little best carbon steel pans. Therefore far as they ought to be cheap, the performance of the pan ought to be integrated into its worth.


Carbon steel pan will last for decades if properly preserved. It’s used for different functions and will greatly improve your cooking experience. It Is an excellent alternative to other cookware choices as It’s a healthy and natural choice. If You Would like a non-stick surface on your pans

Your choices may not be the most expensive or the cheapest. By finding the proper blend of size and usability, you may enjoy cooking daily with your best carbon steel pan, if it is for industrial or private use.

About Albana Bennett

I am a baking nerd and resident pastry magician dubbed one of America’s Greatest New Pastry Chefs by Food & Wine. I am always trying to keep it easy in the kitchen. I actually likes making doughs of each type. Spirit meals: Whipped cream.

My Social: Facebook | Twitter | Tumblr | Linkedin

Leave a Comment